Reply

Cast Your Vote:

    • Yes. -- Votes: 54
    • No. -- Votes: 10
    • Honestly I don't know. -- Votes: 3
Would you trade your soul? Minion 3 kids; ., GA, United States 21802 posts
20th Oct '12

This is a question for the Christian mamas, but if you're non-Christian, feel free to join in if you want.



If Satan came to you one day and said that he had kidnapped your child and was going to throw them into Hell forever, and he gives you the option to switch places with your child, what would you do?
Would you save your child and willingly go to Hell and burn forever or would you let Satan keep you child?



Yeah, it's a crazy off-the-wall question, but me and a friend were discussing this the other day.
I added a poll so people could answer honestly.
And don't go around the question by saying it could never happen, there is no Satan, etc. In this hypothetical situation it did happen.

The One You've Missed 16 kids; Texas 32426 posts
20th Oct '12

I think 99% of mamas would say yes they would....



but I dont believe in hell so I say no. Because there is no devil. lol

P E N I S Due February 27; 34 kids; Washington 13746 posts
20th Oct '12

I would, yes.




there isn't anything I wouldn't do for my children.

Arks Mama! ಠ_ಠ 1 child; Utah 2401 posts
20th Oct '12

Sounds like either way you're going to hell. :P

Olive ♥ 1 child; North Carolina 4902 posts
20th Oct '12

Yes. I would do anything for my son and for any future kids I'll have.

FroggysMommy 1 child; Golden, Colorado 27489 posts
20th Oct '12
Quoting Minion:" This is a question for the Christian mamas, but if you're non-Christian, feel free to join in if you ... [snip!] ... And don't go around the question by saying it could never happen, etc. In this hypothetical situation it did happen. "


I don't believe in Hell or a devil, I do believe in eternal sin though. Its weird.



But I would gladly trade for my daughter.

TayNoelle Due January 22; 2 kids; 1 angel baby; Sacramento, Ca, United States 1062 posts
20th Oct '12

I would most definitely take my child's place

♥Mama Constantine 2 kids; 3 angel babies; Texas 5821 posts
20th Oct '12

I would absolutely trade.
If anything, I deserve to be in Hell for the things I've done.
My children are completely innocent.

CRSx2Mommy 18 kids; North Carolina 3475 posts
20th Oct '12
Quoting P E N I S
Madi's*Mama Due November 2; 1 child; Holland, Michigan 7391 posts
20th Oct '12

If I knew for sure the Devil had dd and knew it wasn't a trick I would def trade places...and typing out this response it occurred to me id prob do it regardless bc I wouldn't want to risk him really having her.

Taphath Foose Due November 29 (boy); 1 child; Pennsylvania 194 posts
20th Oct '12

I'm just curious but why would you even ask that if you know it's not possible?

Vivialopod 2 kids; Vantaa, Finland 42788 posts
20th Oct '12

Well... I mean i'm going to hell anyway so it sounds like a trick to me. But yes of course I would take any source of suffering in my child's place.

Tavi 1 child; Washington 24408 posts
20th Oct '12

Well..I don't believe in these kinds of stories..but, I'll give me answer anyway...



If anybody took my kid and was going to put them in harms way and I had the choice of it being me instead of my kid. Yes. I would in a heartbeat. And once the switch was made, I'd probably plot to kill the doucher.

Minion 3 kids; ., GA, United States 21802 posts
20th Oct '12
Quoting Taphath Foose:" I'm just curious but why would you even ask that if you know it's not possible?"


It's just one of the weird thoughts that go through my head. I imagine lots of hypothetical situations.

Taphath Foose Due November 29 (boy); 1 child; Pennsylvania 194 posts
20th Oct '12

Another thing...there's so many things wrong with this "scenario"!