Reply

Cast Your Vote:

    • Chocolate -- Votes: 1
    • Vanilla -- Votes: 8
    • Marble -- Votes: 6
    • Carrot -- Votes: 3
    • Confetti -- Votes: 6
    • Other (lemme know in comments please lol) -- Votes: 3
Which cake flavor for a first birthday? user banned
10th Nov '12

Thanks :) No clue on frosting either :x

John Mayer. 2 kids; Modesto, California 21992 posts
10th Nov '12

We had vanilla with fresg strawberry filling and whipped cream frosting. :D

Stefan Salvatore Due March 29; 1 child; 1 angel baby; Fort Hood, Texas 11671 posts
10th Nov '12

We made my daughter a vanilla cake with strawberry frosting... She loved it!

*Ashley F* Due December 25 (girl); Bronson, Florida 183 posts
10th Nov '12

for a boy or a girl????




for my niece we made a strawberry cake with creamcheese frosting
but for a boy i would do vanilla but use blue food coloring to dye the batter
but the confetti cakes make a blue vanilla frosting now... and betty crocker makes these packets you can mix into the frosting the change the color and flavor of it

Vivian [♥] 2 kids; Balls Deep, in, Georgia 13923 posts
10th Nov '12

We did a strawberry cake.. mmmmmm

user banned 1 child; Boston, Massachusetts 30985 posts
10th Nov '12
Quoting Keyboard Warrior.:" We had vanilla with fresg strawberry filling and whipped cream frosting. :D"


we had the same one for my daughters 1st (and every other birthday since then)



my son had a chocolate cake with whipped cream frosting. it was very good!

John Mayer. 2 kids; Modesto, California 21992 posts
10th Nov '12
Quoting shes*almost*one!:" we had the same one for my daughters 1st (and every other birthday since then) my son had a chocolate cake with whipped cream frosting. it was very good!"


We had chocolate with strawberries for his second.
I made a smores cake for him this year. So good!

Cαtwomαn 2 kids; 1 angel baby; Gotham, DC, United States 12302 posts
status 10th Nov '12

We did 24 cupcakes. Half chocolate and half vanilla. I gave DS a chocolate one, though.

user banned 1 child; Portland, Maine 20613 posts
10th Nov '12

We're doing a Minnie Mouse theme so right now I'm planning on cutting her smash cake into the shape of Minnie's bow, making it a vanilla cake and I'll probably layer it with strawberries and use a strawberry frosting to make the bow pink. Everyone else will get a Minnie Mouse's head shaped cake to eat :lol:

Charlie's Lovely Mommy 1 child; Granville, Massachusetts 1794 posts
10th Nov '12

e have a garden out back so we picked carrots and made Ds a carrot cake for his birthday, and he loved it so much! He had a huge piece.

Mrs. Curtis 1 child; Lompoc, California 1996 posts
10th Nov '12
Quoting Co-Creator of Goobernut:" We're doing a Minnie Mouse theme so right now I'm planning on cutting her smash cake into the shape of ... [snip!] ... and use a strawberry frosting to make the bow pink. Everyone else will get a Minnie Mouse's head shaped cake to eat :lol:"


thats adorable!! you should test the frosting with her before the actual party.. remember conans party? he had have vanilla half chocolate cupcakes. but the dye was bad.. (you were there so im not going into detail)