I have a 14 month old....
if you kid is like him, he would like the car one better.
I say the car one if she likes cars and trucks.
I naught Liam the farm version of the zoo toy u bought. He never played with it, because unless u put the animal in the right place it won't make noise and stuff.
I naught him the car thing for Christmas. Because he likes putting stuff down ramps and watching it go. So I'd go with the car one.
His 16 months on the 12th