Reply

Cast Your Vote:

    • only if you dontate can you receive on organ -- Votes: 6
    • anyone should be able to get an organ -- Votes: 28
KissMeFinnNelson<3 1 child; 2 angel babies; Glasgow, Scotland, UK, United Kingdom 5396 posts
3rd Feb '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting meggymama:</b>" :( I wonder why they deem it to be neccesary to discriminate? Is there more risk? "</blockquote>




I dont really know.... Apparently it would seem these deviant homosexual and bisexual men are highly toxic and are just going around contaminating all the blood :shock:

user banned Lesbos, Greece 95211 posts
3rd Feb '13
Quoting xTJ:" <blockquote><b>Quoting SAFFY
Andi+Andy=Marley+1 2 kids; Fredericksburg, Virginia 4564 posts
3rd Feb '13

Here's how I see it. It really doesn't matter how many people are donors. Family of the donor would have the rightful say on weather that person becomes an actual donor anyway. Plus, most people are not ideal canidates to be actual donors anyway. The shortage on organs has nothing to do with how many people consent to be organ donors.



So no. I don't think that would be fair at all.

KissMeFinnNelson<3 1 child; 2 angel babies; Glasgow, Scotland, UK, United Kingdom 5396 posts
3rd Feb '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting SAFFY

taking a look at life Palm beach gardens, FL, United States 49130 posts
3rd Feb '13

well i can't donate o how is this even fair one of my test give off a false positive as i have had a deeper test to find out the one that they did when i donated plasma is a false positive because my doctor did many test to make sure i dont have what they said i did and concluded it was a false positive.

user banned Lesbos, Greece 95211 posts
3rd Feb '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting xTJ:</b>" <blockquote><b>Quoting SAFFY

Whitney*JAS*BMM* 2 kids; Texas City, Texas 12660 posts
3rd Feb '13

Thats not really fair at all. DH can not donate, so how would it be fair to tell him sorry because you aren't able to donate because of a disease you have, you have to die.



Its not cut and dry. Some people can not donate at all. its not a simple i don't want to donate.

eKnuckles Due February 13; Florida 3472 posts
3rd Feb '13

I would have a HUGE problem if it was compulsory to donate an organ. My body will NOT be cut up. Now if it was only compulsory to donate should you be wanting an organ yourself, while I don't agree, is not as bad.

eKnuckles Due February 13; Florida 3472 posts
3rd Feb '13

Plus there are so many people murdered for their organs anyway. Organ harvesting is a huge disgusting money maker. When Haiti's was in need of help, their organs were being harvested.

Wiggity Wack 1 child; Connecticut 10780 posts
3rd Feb '13

Absolutely not. That's blackmail of the worst kind. No one should be denied life saving treatment.

KissMeFinnNelson<3 1 child; 2 angel babies; Glasgow, Scotland, UK, United Kingdom 5396 posts
3rd Feb '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting SAFFY

KissMeFinnNelson<3 1 child; 2 angel babies; Glasgow, Scotland, UK, United Kingdom 5396 posts
3rd Feb '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting eKnuckles:</b>" I would have a HUGE problem if it was compulsory to donate an organ. My body will NOT be cut up. Now ... [snip!] ... be cut up. Now if it was only compulsory to donate should you be wanting an organ yourself, while I don't agree, is not as bad."</blockquote>




That wouldn't really work because I would assume it's the same as blood. I don't know what the rules are anywhere else but in the UK if you've been given a blood transfusion you aren't allowed to ever give blood after it. So had you been given an organ donation you wouldn't ever be able to donate.

KissMeFinnNelson<3 1 child; 2 angel babies; Glasgow, Scotland, UK, United Kingdom 5396 posts
3rd Feb '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting eKnuckles:</b>" Plus there are so many people murdered for their organs anyway. Organ harvesting is a huge disgusting money maker. When Haiti's was in need of help, their organs were being harvested."</blockquote>




Exactly there is already an illegal market for human organs, imagine what would happen if this was a law.

eKnuckles Due February 13; Florida 3472 posts
3rd Feb '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting xTJ:</b>" <blockquote><b>Quoting eKnuckles:</b>" I would have a HUGE problem if it was compulsory ... [snip!] ... you aren't allowed to ever give blood after it. So had you been given an organ donation you wouldn't ever be able to donate."</blockquote>




Really? I was not aware of that. I suppose because of the condition the person is/was in.

taking a look at life Palm beach gardens, FL, United States 49130 posts
3rd Feb '13
Quoting xTJ:" <blockquote><b>Quoting eKnuckles:</b>" I would have a HUGE problem if it was compulsory ... [snip!] ... you aren't allowed to ever give blood after it. So had you been given an organ donation you wouldn't ever be able to donate."



Wait for 12 months after receiving a blood transfusion from another person in the United States.