Cast Your Vote:

    • Don't do Scarlett if your oldest girl is Charlotte! -- Votes: 43
    • I think it's cute! Go have yourself a Charlotte and Scarlett! -- Votes: 15
Charlotte and Scarlett The Pretender 2 kids; Brazil 1232 posts
24th Feb '13

Ok, so I have had a list of names for boys and girls that I've kept (and added to) since I got my bfp with my 4 year old.

Her name is Charlotte Evelyn.

My hubby and I, initially, thought of naming our new baby Eileen Esther

existentialism 2 kids; Texas 16990 posts
24th Feb '13

Yes, I think they are very matchy.

Back to Noob Status Ohio 14048 posts
24th Feb '13
Quoting The Pretender:" Ok, so I have had a list of names for boys and girls that I've kept (and added to) since I got my bfp ... [snip!] ... Eileen... Which I am totally in love with too- I just worry about having a Charlotte and a Scarlett. Too matchy matchy?"

WAY too matchy. Although, I think Ruby and Charlotte would be cute!

castaway 2 kids; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 20306 posts
24th Feb '13

Those are way too close! Don't do it, lol.

Atticus & Rhys's Mommy 2 kids; Westfield, Massachusetts 7423 posts
24th Feb '13

I personally love Scarlett, that would of been my youngests name if he had turned out to be a girl. But they match too close in my opinion so no I wouldnt use it!

❀Sarah❀ 2 kids; 2 angel babies; Cocking, EU, Europe 136069 posts
24th Feb '13

Way too matchy IMO

Turtley Mikey Due October 31; 2 kids; California 50611 posts
24th Feb '13

Very similar. I wouldn't use it.

Devil Duckie 3 kids; New York 48700 posts
24th Feb '13

horribly similar. Scarlett should be taken off your list all together and never used.

doors33 1 child; Tonawanda, New York 478 posts
24th Feb '13

Definitely too similar... Does Charlotte have a nickname though? (I hate saying don't use Scarlet, because I just love it SOOOO much.)

Smash Fins ; 2 kids; Denver, Colorado 1479 posts
24th Feb '13

Yeah they really are matchey, but it's cute :)

I wouldn't mind doing that with my kids.

12345mama54321 Nebraska 94 posts
25th Feb '13

I love it, it is matchy, but I just think it's even cuter that way lol....not much different than people starting all their kid's name with the same letter.

Serial Mom ✄ 2 kids; Michigan 2710 posts
25th Feb '13

Way to matchy! I have a Charlotte and if I have another girl someday, I love Violet but worry it's too close. Do you use a nickname for your Charlotte? I call mine Lottie :)

The Pretender 2 kids; Brazil 1232 posts
25th Feb '13

I usually call her "Char" or "Rotten" lol