Reply
peanutbutter kaylenR 2 kids; California 5 posts
21st Mar '13

My son is 2 hes allergic to peanutbutter. what can i substitute for it?

Drunk Blair Waldorf 2 kids; Alpharetta, Georgia 19208 posts
21st Mar '13

Soybutter.

Jennybananna 2 kids; Gilbert, AZ, United States 25079 posts
21st Mar '13

Are you making something specific or are we talking about like a pb&j?

Captain Obvious 2 kids; Havana, Cuba 25634 posts
21st Mar '13
lilmzzgreeneyez *NMOA* 21 kids; Sherwood, Arkansas 17987 posts
21st Mar '13

nutella, soy butter, almond butter, there are all kinds of replacements for peanut butter. i personally did not like the soy or almond butter when i tried it but nutella was awesome on anything. (i would put it with strawberry jam on sandwhiches to substitute pbj for my daughter)

HappyMomTo2 2 kids; Maine 360 posts
21st Mar '13

Soynut butter or Sunbutter. I prefer soy over sunbutter because sunbutter is really oily.

kaylenR 2 kids; California 5 posts
21st Mar '13

Celery and peanutbutter
Bananas and peanutbutter
Peanutbutter and jelly
Everything involves peanutbutter
The soy kind i can only find on a website if it costs 10$ i pay 30$ on top for shipping.

HappyMomTo2 2 kids; Maine 360 posts
21st Mar '13
Quoting lilmzzgreeneyez *NMOA*:" nutella, soy butter, almond butter, there are all kinds of replacements for peanut butter. i personally ... [snip!] ... it but nutella was awesome on anything. (i would put it with strawberry jam on sandwhiches to substitute pbj for my daughter)"


I'm iffy about Nutella because it uses peanut oil. But the peanut oil is super filtered so it is supposed to have no actual peanut protein in it. But I'm still afraid to try it.

lilmzzgreeneyez *NMOA* 21 kids; Sherwood, Arkansas 17987 posts
21st Mar '13

Quoting kaylenR:" Celery and peanutbutter Bananas and peanutbutter Peanutbutter and jelly Everything involves peanutbutter The soy kind i can only find on a website if it costs 10$ i pay 30$ on top for shipping."


walmart should have soy butter... in the section with peanut butter. and they should have various other options too. unless you are opposed to walmart. our local grocer is a kroger and they have it all in the same section too.

eta: the price was about the same as peanut butter too. maybe a dollar more at the most.

lilmzzgreeneyez *NMOA* 21 kids; Sherwood, Arkansas 17987 posts
21st Mar '13
Quoting HappyAndPregnant:" I'm iffy about Nutella because it uses peanut oil. But the peanut oil is super filtered so it is supposed to have no actual peanut protein in it. But I'm still afraid to try it."


oh! i did not know that. it NEVER bothered my daughter. i guess because her allergy wasnt that severe. it was her allergist that had recommended trying nutella.

HappyMomTo2 2 kids; Maine 360 posts
21st Mar '13
Quoting kaylenR:" Celery and peanutbutter Bananas and peanutbutter Peanutbutter and jelly Everything involves peanutbutter The soy kind i can only find on a website if it costs 10$ i pay 30$ on top for shipping."


Yeah it is pretty expensive. I spend almost $5 for soynut butter here.

Captain Obvious 2 kids; Havana, Cuba 25634 posts
21st Mar '13
Quoting kaylenR:" Celery and peanutbutter Bananas and peanutbutter Peanutbutter and jelly Everything involves peanutbutter The soy kind i can only find on a website if it costs 10$ i pay 30$ on top for shipping."



you can get sunbutter at target

whitneynator 1 child; Iowa 4114 posts
21st Mar '13

<blockquote><b>Quoting HappyAndPregnant:</b>" I'm iffy about Nutella because it uses peanut oil. But the peanut oil is super filtered so it is supposed to have no actual peanut protein in it. But I'm still afraid to try it."</blockquote>




Check to see where its made. If it is made in Canada it doesn't have peanut oil. My friend who is allergic to all tree nuts told me that. (she is also from Canada)

kaylenR 2 kids; California 5 posts
21st Mar '13

I did shop at walmart but will never again. I found bird feathers in my bag of grapes. Disgusting. Ive never noticed a soy kind of peanut butter but ill check that out thankyou

lilmzzgreeneyez *NMOA* 21 kids; Sherwood, Arkansas 17987 posts
21st Mar '13
Quoting whitneynator:" <blockquote><b>Quoting HappyAndPregnant:</b>" I'm iffy about Nutella because it uses ... [snip!] ... made in Canada it doesn't have peanut oil. My friend who is allergic to all tree nuts told me that. (she is also from Canada)"

well that makes me wonder if the nutella we get at our stores is from Canada because i always checked labels for my daughter and never once saw peanut oil on the list...