The former WWE star and tech entrepreneur, Stacy Keibler & Jared​ Pobre, are all set to welcome a new member in their family – they already have a five- year daughter, Ava Grace, and 17-month son, Bodhi Brooks, and are expecting their third child in May 2020.

Keibler, 40, shares with PEOPLE, “Seeing the dynamic between our two kids is what made us want to have more kids.” They live in Jackson Hole, [Wyoming], and the mother-of-two feels it’s really “nice to just have a little tribe there.”

The would-be father adds equally excitedly “It’s exciting. I think once we had our second one, we totally got it and understood how to manage.” In the last week of August, they found that they were pregnant with their third child, and what more? The couple took the test together and revealed the awesome news to each other at the same time!

However, they didn't inform the family immediately, particularly their eldest daughter Ava.  “We wanted to wait until we were going to tell our parents. So we told her basically the day before,” Pobre says. “Yeah, because she would tell everybody,” Keibler laughs. “Which is exactly what she did.”

They shared the news with their kids about their little brother or sister, with a picture of the sonogram. Keibler says, “We had a picture of the first sonogram and we brought my daughter in, My son — he’s too little. He was there with us when we told Ava, but she’s 5. So we expected her to be excited and we showed her a picture of the sonogram and we just said, ‘We have some really exciting news.’”

The third-time mom shares little Ava was jumping up down with joy, and it was "heartwarming" to see her happy. The couple has not shared the gender of the baby but says that the 5-year-old wants to have a little sister. She already has a brother, so for obvious reasons, she wants a sister now!

The former Miss Maryland Pre-Teen explained to her daughter, “Well, you have to be happy for whatever God blesses us with.” They have two lovely kids, and Ava is a great elder sibling to Bodhi, as they are always seen together in the house. The mom reveals how Bodhi cries when his sister leaves for school but then he screams when she's back. She continues, "He hears her at the door and just screams. … Seeing that every day is why we want to have more.”

Both Keibler and Pobre have been a single child, and their parents were equally happy and shocked to learn about the third child. After meeting for the first time through a mutual friend ten years ago, Pobre and Keibler had always kept in touch. Then, fortuitously, when they were seated next to each other on a flight, they reconnected. They tied the knot in 2014, and from the first moment, Pobre knew he wanted a big family with Keibler.

RELATED: ‘Little Women’ Star Terra Jole Reveals She’s Pregnant With Her Third Child